Star Trek: Discovery, Season 2 Week 4 (Episode 4) Weekly Discussion Thread

Home Forums Star Trek TV Series Star Trek: DSC Star Trek: Discovery, Season 2 Week 4 (Episode 4) Weekly Discussion Thread

  • Author
    Posts
  • #2179

    Jules Sherred
    Keymaster

    @jules-sherred

    100
    80
    • Points for New Members Icon
    • Points for Each Blog Post Icon
    • Points for Each Comment Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Post Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Reply Icon
    • Points for Updating Your Avatar Icon

    This is a no spoiler post but there will be spoilers in the replies, so don’t scroll down to the replies unless you’re prepared to read spoilers. This discussion thread will be pinned until next Thursday.

    Once you’ve finished watching An Obol for Charon come join the discussion!

    I’ll be doing weekly recaps and commentary on Sundays at GeekDad.com and will use some comments from this community if they fit. If you don’t want your comment used, please say that when you comment.

    Live Long and Prosper!

    PS: I won’t get a chance to watch this episode until later tonight, so you won’t see me in the comments until tomorrow.

    episode until later tonight, so you won’t see me in the comments until tomorrow.

    "Logic Is The Beginning Of Wisdom, Not The End." -Leonard Nimoy

  • #2181

    Scott Carpenter
    Participant

    @scott-carpenter

    200
    40
    • Points for New Members Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Post Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Reply Icon
    • Points for Updating Your Avatar Icon

    I’m still watching the episode (Tilly is trapped in the booth), and this isn’t so much a comment on this episode, anyway, but…

    The creature was trying to communicate with Tilly – said repeatedly that she/it had important information – and Starfleet’s goal is to find and communicate with different life forms. Why didn’t anyone tell Tilly to ask it what it wanted? Why didn’t Tilly think to ask?

  • #2182

    Jules Sherred
    Keymaster

    @jules-sherred

    100
    80
    • Points for New Members Icon
    • Points for Each Blog Post Icon
    • Points for Each Comment Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Post Icon
    • Points for Each Forum Reply Icon
    • Points for Updating Your Avatar Icon

    @scott-carpenter Let me know if you’ve done watching so I can add my two cents. I’m going to start typing the GeekDad article at around 1 pm Pacific time.

    @g-h-brothers What did you think?

    "Logic Is The Beginning Of Wisdom, Not The End." -Leonard Nimoy

    • #2183

      Scott Carpenter
      Participant

      @scott-carpenter

      200
      40
      • Points for New Members Icon
      • Points for Each Forum Post Icon
      • Points for Each Forum Reply Icon
      • Points for Updating Your Avatar Icon

      Sorry – got busy. Done watching now.

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Skip to toolbar
United Federation of Planets

FREE
VIEW